Mr. Gorman, why…? I’m not ready to comment on you; but see what you have stirred up?
Jill’s asking for ideas on implementing a suggestion to start a list of blogging GSLISers. Wheeew! I don’t know how to feel about that possiblity. I’m not hiding my presence in the slightest, but I’m not advertising either. Would I want a link to here from school/work? My 1st reaction is to keep them separate. It is one of the few areas of my life that isn’t entirely school/work. Even my website is out of sight behind the LEEP server. It is kept separate in a vastly different and possibly more efficient way. This is only separate until people discover it on a search as simple as entry level librarian. And like that isn’t something someone in LIS might search for….
Mr. Gorman, you are going to have to wait. I have nothing to add but maybe I should lay out my thoughts for myself. I used to defend you sir. It will take me longer now to urge others to more moderate interpretations of your comments. I do not believe that you are a Luddite but that you ask highly relevant and appropriate questions about many things. But that LJ Backtalk piece? And don’t tell me it was satire. I agree with your general characterization of Google’s ‘efficiency’ and with much of your assessment of the value of the digitization project. But please tell me, you are smart enough to know that what you mean by ‘efficiency’ is not the same as the readers of the LA Times mean by an efficient search engine?
[NOTE: Put in links to some of the better posts from the last week and a half over Gormangate.]
You have forced your way into my life with your comments, in several
ways, sir. I have generally appreciated your views before but the
difference is that I chose to take them in. In this case, most
everyone I read was talking about it so I had no choice.
You are coming to visit us on the 21st of April. Need to re-schedule my dental appointment.
As you took none of my dignity I want none of yours sir. Here are my comments on Our Singular Strengths: Meditations for Librarians from the Professional Development page of my portfolio for my 1st library school class last summer:
Again, a very wise man. His first koan, Opening the
Door, where I learned that he, as dean of libraries at California State
University at Fresno, opens the doors to his library each morning made
me cry. What a difference from the academic library that I work at!
Read 25-27 July 2004.
I don’t expect many of the folks who were offended by your
comments—finding them offensive is different—would understand open or
closing a library on a regular basis. I did it for 6 years to include
most holidays during this time and within seconds of opening Our Singular Strengths
I was crying. I was somewhere different then than now, oh, the story
of my life, but…you know, I’m going to leave it at our deans didn’t
open (or close) the building. It was done by a handful of students
and even fewer staff (I was both). If it wasn’t for believing the 1st
clause of the next paragraph, I would say that one can not really
understand the rhythm of their library if they aren’t involved in
opening and closing it on a regular basis. Everyone is important, but
do you spend enough time thinking about these very special and often
very few library workers.
There are lots of ways to experience our libraries people and lots
of ways to have conversations too. I agree in both Mr. Gorman’s
reviewed, edited & published form and the form of blogs and other
tools of conversation. There are also forms in-between these. Let’s
use them. And not everyone has to use them all, but we should all use
a few different ones. I think it is pretty much a given that the Blog
People I know of, follow, and possibly respect, are all readers of
sustained text. And I absolutely love a grand conversation through the
literature of a discipline, but come Mr. Gorman, it is a pretty darn
slow way to have all conversation.
This feeds into one of the main reasons that I’m not so sure I want
this blog widely know throughout the on-line library world. This isn’t
a library blog. It’s about the parts of me I’m ready to release
publicly. And after 20 years in the service giving up my
Constitutional rights while defending those of others, having a son
sent to this damn war, seeing what has happened with our government and
society since 2001…let’s just say I have some things to talk about.
Often it will have nothing to do with the library world and maybe
shouldn’t. I’m not advocating a fractured, role-playing existence
because I don’t. My point is that I don’t want to be judged on the
rules of do I make the profession of librarianship look good (always).
Darn, that comment will need explicating. Later. I didn’t mean to get anywhere near this involved. Damn you Michael Gorman.